{
  "scope": "Fixed 20-project portfolio; 8,570 valid qualifying answer records after one empty capture exclusion. Configured Peec AI brand detections, not exhaustive semantic recommendations or a causal effect.",
  "window": {
    "start": "2026-08-01",
    "end": "2026-10-30"
  },
  "study": {
    "schema": 1,
    "scope": "Fixed 20-project portfolio; recorded ChatGPT UI metadata/query rows Aug 1-Oct 30. Provider mention labels, not full-text annotation of all responses. No causal effects or population success probabilities.",
    "input_answers": 78545,
    "input_queries": 206913,
    "input_question_ids": 1057,
    "unbranded_input_question_ids": 948,
    "primary": {
      "answers": 8570,
      "provider_mentions": 1344,
      "mention_share": 0.15682613768961493,
      "questions": 742,
      "projects": 20,
      "projects_with_mentions": 20,
      "positive_dates": 84
    },
    "monthly": {
      "2026-08": {
        "answers": 2821,
        "provider_mentions": 407,
        "mention_share": 0.14427507975895074,
        "questions": 561,
        "projects": 20,
        "projects_with_mentions": 17,
        "positive_dates": 24
      },
      "2026-09": {
        "answers": 3428,
        "provider_mentions": 554,
        "mention_share": 0.161610268378063,
        "questions": 586,
        "projects": 19,
        "projects_with_mentions": 17,
        "positive_dates": 30
      },
      "2026-10": {
        "answers": 2321,
        "provider_mentions": 383,
        "mention_share": 0.16501507970702284,
        "questions": 605,
        "projects": 19,
        "projects_with_mentions": 16,
        "positive_dates": 30
      }
    },
    "strata": {
      "brand_named_in_other_queries": {
        "answers": 427,
        "provider_mentions": 346,
        "mention_share": 0.810304449648712,
        "questions": 95,
        "projects": 15,
        "projects_with_mentions": 15,
        "positive_dates": 80
      },
      "brand_absent_all_query_text": {
        "answers": 8143,
        "provider_mentions": 998,
        "mention_share": 0.12255925334643251,
        "questions": 725,
        "projects": 20,
        "projects_with_mentions": 19,
        "positive_dates": 84
      },
      "all_queries_contain_site_operator": {
        "answers": 21,
        "provider_mentions": 0,
        "mention_share": 0.0,
        "questions": 14,
        "projects": 7,
        "projects_with_mentions": 0,
        "positive_dates": 0
      }
    },
    "monthly_strata": {
      "2026-08": {
        "brand_named_in_other_queries": {
          "answers": 179,
          "provider_mentions": 140,
          "mention_share": 0.7821229050279329,
          "questions": 60,
          "projects": 12,
          "projects_with_mentions": 12,
          "positive_dates": 24
        },
        "brand_absent_all_query_text": {
          "answers": 2642,
          "provider_mentions": 267,
          "mention_share": 0.10105980317940953,
          "questions": 543,
          "projects": 20,
          "projects_with_mentions": 15,
          "positive_dates": 24
        },
        "all_queries_contain_site_operator": {
          "answers": 4,
          "provider_mentions": 0,
          "mention_share": 0.0,
          "questions": 3,
          "projects": 2,
          "projects_with_mentions": 0,
          "positive_dates": 0
        }
      },
      "2026-09": {
        "brand_named_in_other_queries": {
          "answers": 144,
          "provider_mentions": 114,
          "mention_share": 0.7916666666666666,
          "questions": 61,
          "projects": 13,
          "projects_with_mentions": 13,
          "positive_dates": 30
        },
        "brand_absent_all_query_text": {
          "answers": 3284,
          "provider_mentions": 440,
          "mention_share": 0.13398294762484775,
          "questions": 571,
          "projects": 19,
          "projects_with_mentions": 15,
          "positive_dates": 30
        },
        "all_queries_contain_site_operator": {
          "answers": 12,
          "provider_mentions": 0,
          "mention_share": 0.0,
          "questions": 9,
          "projects": 7,
          "projects_with_mentions": 0,
          "positive_dates": 0
        }
      },
      "2026-10": {
        "brand_named_in_other_queries": {
          "answers": 104,
          "provider_mentions": 92,
          "mention_share": 0.8846153846153846,
          "questions": 52,
          "projects": 12,
          "projects_with_mentions": 12,
          "positive_dates": 26
        },
        "brand_absent_all_query_text": {
          "answers": 2217,
          "provider_mentions": 291,
          "mention_share": 0.13125845737483086,
          "questions": 583,
          "projects": 19,
          "projects_with_mentions": 15,
          "positive_dates": 30
        },
        "all_queries_contain_site_operator": {
          "answers": 5,
          "provider_mentions": 0,
          "mention_share": 0.0,
          "questions": 5,
          "projects": 4,
          "projects_with_mentions": 0,
          "positive_dates": 0
        }
      }
    },
    "question_distribution": {
      "all_eligible": 742,
      "with_at_least_10_eligible_answers": {
        "questions": 330,
        "projects": 18,
        "answers": 6846,
        "provider_mentions": 1054,
        "question_equal_mention_share": 0.15565803825772284,
        "project_equal_mention_share": 0.1409172173953569,
        "questions_with_mentions": 137
      },
      "zero_mentions": 193,
      "positive_below_half": 91,
      "at_least_half": 46
    },
    "prompt_intents_min10": {
      "evaluation_decision": {
        "questions": 36,
        "projects": 9,
        "answers": 870,
        "provider_mentions": 228,
        "question_equal_mention_share": 0.2521040832486029,
        "project_equal_mention_share": 0.1168820765206151,
        "questions_with_mentions": 18
      },
      "explanation_implementation": {
        "questions": 28,
        "projects": 11,
        "answers": 561,
        "provider_mentions": 63,
        "question_equal_mention_share": 0.09961127682164267,
        "project_equal_mention_share": 0.0884747605396164,
        "questions_with_mentions": 9
      },
      "named_alternative_comparison": {
        "questions": 32,
        "projects": 9,
        "answers": 629,
        "provider_mentions": 77,
        "question_equal_mention_share": 0.17349830928875046,
        "project_equal_mention_share": 0.20593135622547387,
        "questions_with_mentions": 13
      },
      "provider_discovery": {
        "questions": 234,
        "projects": 17,
        "answers": 4786,
        "provider_mentions": 686,
        "question_equal_mention_share": 0.14508694008484113,
        "project_equal_mention_share": 0.1391721754576056,
        "questions_with_mentions": 97
      }
    },
    "explicit_wording_features_min10": {
      "explicit_capability_or_integration": {
        "yes": {
          "questions": 229,
          "projects": 17,
          "answers": 5001,
          "provider_mentions": 734,
          "question_equal_mention_share": 0.15662918841498252,
          "project_equal_mention_share": 0.15323004427071021,
          "questions_with_mentions": 96
        },
        "no": {
          "questions": 101,
          "projects": 18,
          "answers": 1845,
          "provider_mentions": 320,
          "question_equal_mention_share": 0.15345612354472818,
          "project_equal_mention_share": 0.12815695578592015,
          "questions_with_mentions": 41
        },
        "within_project_min2_each": {
          "projects": 15,
          "higher": 8,
          "lower": 6,
          "equal": 1,
          "mean_difference": 0.017341800512244748
        }
      },
      "explicit_user_or_business_context": {
        "yes": {
          "questions": 260,
          "projects": 18,
          "answers": 5528,
          "provider_mentions": 727,
          "question_equal_mention_share": 0.13408135907568955,
          "project_equal_mention_share": 0.11480024727003722,
          "questions_with_mentions": 99
        },
        "no": {
          "questions": 70,
          "projects": 12,
          "answers": 1318,
          "provider_mentions": 327,
          "question_equal_mention_share": 0.2357999895052751,
          "project_equal_mention_share": 0.18369722975934283,
          "questions_with_mentions": 38
        },
        "within_project_min2_each": {
          "projects": 8,
          "higher": 3,
          "lower": 4,
          "equal": 1,
          "mean_difference": -0.07325476744106872
        }
      },
      "quantified_context_or_constraint": {
        "yes": {
          "questions": 58,
          "projects": 14,
          "answers": 1260,
          "provider_mentions": 99,
          "question_equal_mention_share": 0.07236687700187568,
          "project_equal_mention_share": 0.099146405408861,
          "questions_with_mentions": 13
        },
        "no": {
          "questions": 272,
          "projects": 18,
          "answers": 5586,
          "provider_mentions": 955,
          "question_equal_mention_share": 0.1734186535255138,
          "project_equal_mention_share": 0.1563597974364886,
          "questions_with_mentions": 124
        },
        "within_project_min2_each": {
          "projects": 9,
          "higher": 3,
          "lower": 6,
          "equal": 0,
          "mean_difference": -0.029844523040701943
        }
      }
    },
    "fixed_panel": {
      "stable_tracking_questions": 666,
      "common_eligible_questions": 397,
      "historical_excluded_questions": 0,
      "monthly": {
        "2026-08": {
          "questions": 397,
          "projects": 18,
          "question_equal_share": 0.1458203988764072,
          "project_equal_share": 0.1311049324529095
        },
        "2026-09": {
          "questions": 397,
          "projects": 18,
          "question_equal_share": 0.182744529152574,
          "project_equal_share": 0.1685674122042096
        },
        "2026-10": {
          "questions": 397,
          "projects": 18,
          "question_equal_share": 0.18224382649667878,
          "project_equal_share": 0.17255289694903334
        }
      },
      "wording_validation_complete": true
    },
    "annotation": {
      "codebook_sha256": "06569d776460c7a87946261a0c01e1de769d789445a9e372ead1f2105fa441e3",
      "labels_sha256": "61db04a2e8a1a7771add75c59cdf3b67fb8bd79cc60f84c90d58eaff698ae58a",
      "method": "Question-only, outcome-withheld AI-assisted coding under frozen codebook; independent subset review."
    }
  },
  "source_audit": {
    "frame": "Only the 1,344 provider-positive answers in the 8,570 eligible answers; all include broader queries. These are citation annotations, not browser re-observation.",
    "positive_frame": 1344,
    "own_domain_cited": 894,
    "brand_absent_any_query_frame": 998,
    "own_domain_cited_brand_absent_any_query": 667
  },
  "context_audit": {
    "selection": "Up to two positive cases per brand per month. Deliberately selected positives, not a population win rate. Two independent AI-assisted passes and conservative adjudication.",
    "selected": 94,
    "final_eligible": 92,
    "clear_suitable_options": 80,
    "brands_with_suitable_examples": 19,
    "October_brands_with_suitable_examples": 14,
    "incidental": 6,
    "qualified": 6
  },
  "privacy": "Named positive illustrations and the named top-two combined aggregate are published with Niklas\u2019s explicit authorization. Internal project/chat IDs, full monitoring exports and individual negative client cases remain private. These are selected positive examples, not an open row-level dataset or a representative recommendation-rate sample.",
  "revision": "v11: editorial naming and retrieval-label clarification; v10 population, measurements and numerical results unchanged.",
  "matched_site_target_comparison": {
    "unit": "Mean of per-question Peec AI recorded brand-mention shares; each question counts equally. Nonbrand questions, minimum five answers per condition. Naturally chosen queries; no causal or statistical significance claim.",
    "primary": {
      "questions": 60,
      "brands": 14,
      "directions": {
        "higher": 55,
        "equal": 5
      },
      "question_equal": {
        "own_site_targeted_rate": 0.9158360878263113,
        "own_site_absent_other_sites_targeted_rate": 0.5281296332626197,
        "own_minus_absent_percentage_points": 38.77064545636916,
        "absent_vs_own_relative_difference_percent": -42.3336074781561,
        "own_to_absent_ratio": 1.7341122901371058
      },
      "brand_equal": {
        "own_site_targeted_rate": 0.962792931269691,
        "own_site_absent_other_sites_targeted_rate": 0.48073462308617804,
        "own_minus_absent_percentage_points": 48.205830818351295,
        "absent_vs_own_relative_difference_percent": -50.0687419409898,
        "own_to_absent_ratio": 2.002753463207699
      },
      "median_within_question_gap_pp": 34.44444444444444
    },
    "ordinary_brand_named_sensitivity": {
      "baseline_on_identical_question_set": {
        "questions": 21,
        "brands": 4,
        "directions": {
          "higher": 18,
          "equal": 3
        },
        "question_equal": {
          "own_site_targeted_rate": 0.9139157918198122,
          "own_site_absent_other_sites_targeted_rate": 0.64692803108489,
          "own_minus_absent_percentage_points": 26.698776073492215,
          "absent_vs_own_relative_difference_percent": -29.213606234255927,
          "own_to_absent_ratio": 1.4127008691943477
        },
        "brand_equal": {
          "own_site_targeted_rate": 0.9620810001432568,
          "own_site_absent_other_sites_targeted_rate": 0.6718167651016903,
          "own_minus_absent_percentage_points": 29.02642350415665,
          "absent_vs_own_relative_difference_percent": -30.170457061135735,
          "own_to_absent_ratio": 1.432058635806194
        },
        "median_within_question_gap_pp": 24.294670846394983
      },
      "other_queries_already_name_brand": {
        "questions": 21,
        "brands": 4,
        "directions": {
          "higher": 10,
          "lower": 5,
          "equal": 6
        },
        "question_equal": {
          "own_site_targeted_rate": 0.9139157918198122,
          "own_site_absent_other_sites_targeted_rate": 0.8321747093486225,
          "own_minus_absent_percentage_points": 8.174108247118973,
          "absent_vs_own_relative_difference_percent": -8.944049681910492,
          "own_to_absent_ratio": 1.0982258671801886
        },
        "brand_equal": {
          "own_site_targeted_rate": 0.9620810001432568,
          "own_site_absent_other_sites_targeted_rate": 0.9449323265050167,
          "own_minus_absent_percentage_points": 1.714867363824013,
          "absent_vs_own_relative_difference_percent": -1.7824563249546177,
          "own_to_absent_ratio": 1.0181480442114488
        },
        "median_within_question_gap_pp": 0.0
      }
    },
    "october_only": {
      "questions": 9,
      "brands": 2,
      "directions": {
        "higher": 5,
        "equal": 3,
        "lower": 1
      },
      "question_equal": {
        "own_site_targeted_rate": 0.8912393162393162,
        "own_site_absent_other_sites_targeted_rate": 0.7484567901234568,
        "own_minus_absent_percentage_points": 14.27825261158594,
        "absent_vs_own_relative_difference_percent": -16.020671834625322,
        "own_to_absent_ratio": 1.1907692307692308
      },
      "brand_equal": {
        "own_site_targeted_rate": 0.9388221153846155,
        "own_site_absent_other_sites_targeted_rate": 0.6944444444444444,
        "own_minus_absent_percentage_points": 24.437767094017104,
        "absent_vs_own_relative_difference_percent": -26.030242250956636,
        "own_to_absent_ratio": 1.3519038461538464
      },
      "median_within_question_gap_pp": 2.2222222222222254
    }
  },
  "display_notes": {
    "main_result": "1,344 recorded mentions among 8,570 valid qualifying answers (15.7%); 7,226 without a recorded mention. One empty record excluded.",
    "comparison": "Separate selected group of 60 questions across 14 client projects, minimum five answers per condition. 55 questions favor own-domain targeting and five tie. Detailed per-question average rates remain in methods.",
    "source_visuals": "Original LinkedIn screenshots establish the discussion. Two original Peec AI research charts show query frequency, not answer mentions; dated snapshots do not form a fixed-panel trend. The irrelevant OpenAI interface image is removed.",
    "time_chart": "Same unchanged fixed-question panel and full-precision monthly shares, rendered as a straight line through three observed monthly points. No smoothing, extrapolation or growth claim.",
    "source_use": "Same valid cohort split into cited own-domain page, uncited own-domain source, and no own-domain source recorded. Rates count configured detections."
  },
  "external_context": {
    "source_audit": "Private evidence packet: peec-ai-source-audit-v8.json",
    "note": "Two third-party query-frequency snapshots, not brand mention results or a common-panel trend. Original own-study numeric outputs unchanged."
  },
  "raw_export": {
    "tracking_records": 78546,
    "query_rows": 206932
  },
  "answer_quality_exclusion": {
    "records": 1,
    "reason": "An eligible record had no saved assistant answer and was absent from the current report population. Excluded from answer denominators, not counted as a nonmention.",
    "affected_month": "2026-09",
    "prior_candidate_records": 8571,
    "valid_qualifying_answers": 8570
  },
  "source_use": {
    "population": 8570,
    "metric": "Configured final-answer brand detection, joined separately to recorded own-domain source presence/citation.",
    "groups": {
      "cited": {
        "answers": 959,
        "mentions": 894,
        "nonmentions": 65,
        "recorded_mention_share": 0.9322210636079249,
        "projects": 20,
        "projects_with_mentions": 20,
        "questions": 227
      },
      "uncited_only": {
        "answers": 1295,
        "mentions": 245,
        "nonmentions": 1050,
        "recorded_mention_share": 0.1891891891891892,
        "projects": 20,
        "projects_with_mentions": 15,
        "questions": 325
      },
      "none": {
        "answers": 6316,
        "mentions": 205,
        "nonmentions": 6111,
        "recorded_mention_share": 0.0324572514249525,
        "projects": 20,
        "projects_with_mentions": 13,
        "questions": 677
      }
    },
    "validation": {
      "original_positive_capture_checks": 1344,
      "positive_disagreements": 0,
      "separate_hash_sample_full_captures": 116,
      "sample_disagreements": 0,
      "population_coverage": 8570
    },
    "limits": [
      "Source presence/citations and final mentions are observed jointly; no intervention was tested.",
      "No recorded mention is not proof that every short-form brand name was absent.",
      "A website hyperlink is separate from a retrieved source.",
      "No own-domain source does not by itself establish a third-party introduction."
    ],
    "group_definitions": {
      "cited": "At least one own-domain page explicitly cited in the answer.",
      "uncited_only": "Own-domain URL recorded as retrieved by Peec AI, with no own-domain citation.",
      "none": "No own-domain URL in the complete recorded source data. Retrieval does not prove full-page reading or influence on the answer."
    }
  },
  "brand_concentration": {
    "selection": "The two projects with the highest recorded mention counts, selected retrospectively; other 18 retained. Different products, markets and buyer questions.",
    "groups": {
      "top_two_projects": {
        "answers": 1839,
        "mentions": 748,
        "recorded_mention_share": 0.4067427949972811,
        "own_source_answers": 934,
        "own_source_share": 0.5078847199564981,
        "project_names": [
          "Allianz Suisse",
          "Heyflow"
        ]
      },
      "remaining_eighteen_projects": {
        "answers": 6731,
        "mentions": 596,
        "recorded_mention_share": 0.0885455355816372,
        "own_source_answers": 1320,
        "own_source_share": 0.1961075620264448
      }
    },
    "top_two_share_of_answers": 0.21458576429404902,
    "top_two_share_of_mentions": 0.5565476190476191
  },
  "third_party_source_diagnostic": {
    "population": "205 Peec AI-recorded mentions without an own-domain source, from the 8570 valid qualifying answers",
    "measurement": "Current Peec AI source-row brand annotations for URLs in historical answer source lists. Not final-answer labels, verified page-body text, or verified page content at answer date.",
    "groups": {
      "annotated_thirdparty_cited": {
        "answers": 166,
        "recorded_mentions": 166,
        "recorded_share": 1.0,
        "projects": 12
      },
      "annotated_thirdparty_retrieved_uncited": {
        "answers": 25,
        "recorded_mentions": 25,
        "recorded_share": 1.0,
        "projects": 9
      },
      "no_matching_source_annotation": {
        "answers": 14,
        "recorded_mentions": 14,
        "recorded_share": 1.0,
        "projects": 7
      }
    },
    "limits": [
      "Source-row annotations do not prove literal page-body wording; historical content versions were not checked for all URLs.",
      "No matching source annotation does not prove every retrieved page was brand-free.",
      "Current content diagnostic, not causal historical attribution."
    ]
  },
  "named_positive_examples": [
    {
      "brand": "Heyflow",
      "date": "2026-10-21",
      "prompt": "What is the best funnel builder for Meta Ads with native Conversions API?",
      "finding": "Recommended first for Meta Ads lead generation; own comparison cited four times, with no own-domain site: target or query naming Heyflow.",
      "source": "https://heyflow.com/blog/best-funnel-builder-for-meta/"
    },
    {
      "brand": "Stackfield",
      "date": "2026-10-12",
      "prompt": "Beste Alternativen zu MeisterTask",
      "finding": "Recommended for privacy-focused collaboration; a third-party comparison that already listed Stackfield was cited twice, with no own-domain source recorded.",
      "source": "https://thedigitalprojectmanager.com/de/tools/beste-meistertask-alternativen/"
    },
    {
      "brand": "Cleversoft",
      "date": "2026-10-01",
      "prompt_excerpt": "Which RegTech platforms integrate supervisory reporting and investor documentation in one suite?",
      "finding": "Among the clearest matches for the insurer\u2019s requirements; own website cited without an own-domain site: target.",
      "source": "https://www.clever-soft.com/"
    }
  ]
}
